Previewing the Tuesday council by-election of 30 Nov 2021

One by-election on Tuesday 30 November 2021:

Franche and Habberley North

Wyre Forest council, Worcestershire; caused by the resignation of Health Concern councillor Susie Griffiths.

Wyre Forest, Franche/Habberley N

For a rare Tuesday by-election we travel to the Worcestershire town of Kidderminster. The Franche and Habberley North ward is the north-western of Kidderminster's six electoral wards. Franche, an old village which has been swallowed up by Kidderminster's growth, lies on the main road towards Bridgnorth, while the Habberley area can be found on the western edge of the town.

Kidderminster is the main town in the Wyre Forest district, where politics has never been quite the same since the rise of the Health Concern party at the start of this century in protest at the removal of A&E facilities at Kidderminster Hospital. Health Concern's fortunes have ebbed and flowed a bit over the two decades since then. They were on a high tide in 2019, winning eight seats across Wyre Forest including all three seats in this ward; but that was in a rather fragmented political scene. Health Concern's winning score in Franche and Habberley North was just 30%; the lead Conservative and Labour candidates tied for the runner-up spot on 20% each; UKIP had 11% and the Greens scored 10%.

Wyre Forest, 2019

From 2015 to 2019 Franche and Habberley North ward had split its representation between two Conservative councillors and one Labour; Franche, the main predecessor ward, had elected councillors on the Conservative, Health Concern, Labour and UKIP tickets between 2004 and 2015. From this you might conclude that this is a politically volatile area.

You might also conclude that from the makeup of Wyre Forest council, which is hung. The Conservatives are the largest party on 12 seats, but the adminstration is made up of a coalition of Health Concern (9 plus this vacancy), the Liberal Democrats (3) and the Greens (1). The Health Concern group includes two councillors who have defected from the Conservatives since 2019, but the ruling coalition is still in a minority; five independents and two Labour councillors hold the balance of power.

However, the county elections here tell a different story. Franche and Habberley North ward only dates from 2015, but it has the same boundaries as the St Barnabas division of Worcestershire county council which was last redrawn in 2005. This county division has been in Conservative hands since 2009, and in May this year the Conservatives had a strong lead: 46%, against 24% for Labour and 20% for Health Concern. Rather the contrast with what happened here in May 2019.

The Health Concern candidate here in the county elections was Susie Griffiths, who had served as a district councillor for this ward since 2019; she is the daughter of Health Concern's party leader Graham Ballinger. Griffiths stood down in October, choosing to focus on her mental health and wellbeing.

There is no Health Concern candidate in the resulting by-election. We have a free-for-all, I repeat we have a free-for-all! Susie Griffiths has signed the nomination papers for independent candidate Doug Hine, who has previously contested Wyre Forest elections on the Green Party ticket. On paper the Conservatives may be best placed for a pickup, and they have selected David Ross: Ross was elected in May as the Conservative county councillor for St Barnabas, and he is the leader of Kidderminster town council and a former mayor of Kidderminster. Standing for Labour is local government veteran Nigel Knowles, who has represented this area at town, district and county level and served in all the major civic offices (mayor of Kidderminster, chair of Wyre Forest council, and chair of Worcestershire county council); Knowles' first local election win came in London all the way back in 1982, and he was a Labour parliamentary candidate at every general election from 1979 to 2017, usually contesting seats he had little or no chance of winning. UKIP have not returned and the Greens do not seem to be opposing Hine, so the ballot paper is completed by the Lib Dem candidate Oliver Walker.

Parliamentary constituency: Wyre Forest
Worcestershire county council division: St Barnabas (same boundaries)

Doug Hine (Ind)
Nigel Knowles (Lab)
David Ross (C)
Oliver Walker (LD)

May 2021 county council result C 1114 Lab 586 Health Concern 493 Grn 158 LD 76
May 2019 result Health Concern 956/890/651 C 628/536 Lab 628/502 UKIP 338 Grn 318 LD 311
May 2018 result C 993 Lab 696 Health Concern 452 LD 110 UKIP 81 Grn 40
May 2017 county council result C 1405 Lab 898 UKIP 165 LD 89 Grn 55
May 2016 result Lab 867 C 695 Health Concern 436 UKIP 385 Grn 62
May 2015 result C 2006/1930/1347 Lab 1443/1113 UKIP 1039/809/742 Grn 437 TUSC 155/112
May 2013 result C 735 Lab 626 Health Concern 431 UKIP 416 TUSC 44 LD 39
June 2009 result C 1134 Health Concern 902 Lab 668 Lib 127 Grn 101
May 2005 result Lab 2013 C 1534 Health Concern 1531
Previous results in detail

If you enjoyed this preview, there are many more like it - going back to 2016 - in the Andrew's Previews books, which are available to buy now (link) and would make an excellent Christmas present for the discerning psephologist. You can also support future previews by donating to the Local Elections Archive Project (link).

Andrew Teale

Previews: 30 Nov 2017

"All the right votes, but not necessarily in the right order..."

The Met Office might recognise St Andrew's Day as the last day of autumn, but a quick look out of your columnist's window to the brooding, whitened mass of Winter Hill will serve to tell that winter has arrived. Winter is a slow time for local by-elections, partly due to the prevailing weather and partly due to the fact that we are now on the countdown to the May 2018 local elections. That gives by-election watchers the chance to pause for breath as we have just four polls this week, the fewest since the middle of September. All of these are south of the M4 corridor, but that doesn't mean a lack of political diversity with all three major parties having one defence each. Read on...


Maidstone council, Kent; caused by the resignation of Conservative councillor Michael Hemsley who had served since 2015.

Last week we finished on the edge of Kent as the Conservatives held a ward based around the White Cliffs of Dover; this week we move inland to Kent's county town. North ward saw an important development in English history in 1076 with the Trial of Penenden Heath. This trial resolved a dispute between Odo, bishop of Bayeux and earl of Kent, and Lanfranc, archbishop of Canterbury, in Lanfranc's favour. The subsequent Domesday Book records Pinnedenna as the place for Kent's landowners to report to the Shire Court.

Penenden Heath crops up many times later in history: it was a meeting-place in the Peasants' Revolt of 1381, in Wyatt's Rebellion of 1554 and during the Civil War, when the Royalist army assembled here in advance of their loss in the 1648 Battle of Maidstone. Early cricket matches were played on the heath: in August and September 1795 Kent lost to England here by five wickets, proving that the England cricket team can win a match on occasion. In later times Penenden Heath became a place of execution, then a recreation ground, before being built on in the 1960s.

The Heath forms about half of the present North ward, which runs north from Maidstone East railway station along the A229 road (towards Rochester) and the east bank of the Medway. Much of the ward's acreage is taken up by the barracks of Invicta Park, home to 36 Engineer Regiment. This regiment includes two squadrons of Gurkhas, whose presence puts North ward in the top 50 wards in England and Wales for Buddhism. Also within the ward boundaries are Maidstone Prison (as seen in the title sequence of Porridge), and the Gallagher Stadium, home to the non-league football team Maidstone United and the first English football stadium built with 3G artificial turf. The census picked up a significant Polish population at the southern end of the ward, but this may be an effect of the prison which holds a large number of foreign nationals within the UK's penal systems.

Now, in this by-election the stakes are high. North ward is normally a safe Liberal Democrat area, although the Conservatives came close in 2011 and UKIP were not far off winning a seat in 2014. Since the current ward boundaries were introduced in 1979 the Conservatives have won only four seats here: two in that initial 1979 election, one in 1992 and Michael Hemsley's seat in 2015 which came with a majority of just 25 votes over the Lib Dems. Local elections since 2015 do not give much cause for optimism that the Conservatives can hold this one: in the 2016 election the Liberal Democrats won here with 43%, to 24% for the Conservatives and 17% for UKIP; and the Lib Dem had a similar lead in May's Kent county elections in the local Maidstone North East division. To add to that, this by-election will determine who is the largest party on the hung Maidstone council: going into this poll the Lib Dems (who run the council as a minority administration) and Conservatives were tied on 22 seats each, with four independents, four Kippers and two Labour councillors holding the balance of power.

Defending for the Conservatives is Cheryl Taylor-Maggio, chairman of Langley parish council (located a few miles south-east of Maidstone); she fought the county seat here in May. Hoping to return to the borough council is Liberal Democrat candidate Rob Field, who was councillor for Park Wood ward from a November 2006 by-election until standing down in 2012; he works in the health sector. UKIP have not returned to the fray, so the ballot paper is completed by Labour's Maureen Cleator who fought this ward in 2016, and the Greens' Derek Eagle who has stood here on several previous occasions.

Parliamentary constituency: Maidstone and the Weald
Kent county council division: Maidstone North East
ONS Travel to Work Area: Medway
Postcode districts: ME14, ME99

Maureen Cleator (Lab)
Derek Eagle (Grn)
Rob Field (LD)
Cheryl Taylor-Maggio (C)

May 2016 result LD 851 C 473 UKIP 328 Lab 261 Grn 68
May 2015 result C 1255 LD 1230 UKIP 783 Lab 445 Grn 215
May 2014 double vacancy LD 949/597 UKIP 529/479 C 380/334 Lab 206 Grn 199
May 2012 result LD 907 C 381 Lab 206 UKIP 167
May 2011 result LD 871 C 782 Lab 330 UKIP 152 Grn 140
May 2010 result LD 1978 C 1225 Lab 299 UKIP 194 Grn 104
MAy 2008 result LD 1012 C 552 Grn 141
May 2007 result LD 973 C 500 Grn 145 Lab 106 Ind 77
May 2006 result LD 1077 C 530 Grn 141 Lab 129
June 2004 result LD 997 C 486 UKIP 214 Lab 169 Grn 80
May 2003 result LD 849 C 379 Lab 161 UKIP 65
May 2002 result LD 1020/974/841 C 402/390 Lab 226 UKIP 109
May 2000 result LD 762 C 341 Lab 136 Grn 46
May 1999 result LD 844 C 434 Lab 166 Grn 34
May 1998 result LD 684 C 400 Lab 231 Grn 46
May 1996 result LD 839 Lab 393 C 327 Grn 63
May 1995 result LD 655 Lab 580 C 451 Grn 36
May 1994 result LD 967 C 606 Lab 484 Grn 86
May 1992 result C 1165 LD 679 Lab 289
May 1991 result LD 1046 C 797 Lab 351
May 1990 result SLD 1370 C 700 Lab 544
May 1988 double vacancy All 1108/994 C 752/740 Lab 272/251
May 1987 result All 1405 C 1000 Lab 264
May 1986 result All 1067 C 871 Lab 321
May 1984 result All 1206 C 599 Lab 274
May 1983 result All 1681 C 720 Lab 230
May 1982 result All 1203 C 757 Lab 297
May 1980 result Lib 976 C 737 Lab 496 NF 22
May 1979 result Lib 1540/1380/1362 C 1502/1468/1371 Lab 907/867/807


Tandridge council, Surrey; caused by the resignation of Liberal Democrat councillor Caroline Warner who had served since 2016. She is moving away from the area.

We move west along the North Downs and inside the M25 motorway, although just outside the Greater London boundary, to the town of Caterham. Administratively Caterham is not one town, but two: Westway lies within the western half, known as Caterham on the Hill for obvious reasons. We retain a link with the Army: much of Westway ward was formerly occupied by Caterham Barracks, which closed in the 1990s with the site having been redeveloped for housing in the 1990s and 2000s.

Westway is the most deprived of the five wards covering Caterham on the Hill and Caterham Valley, and despite high employment levels has relatively large amounts of social housing. This enabled the ward to vote Labour at the height of Tony Blair's powers, and as recently as 2002 Labour polled 36% of the vote here. The Lib Dems got ahead of Labour in the 2004 election, and then the Labour vote collapsed in their favour to create a Lib Dem/Tory marginal. Since 2008 the ward's two seats have been split between the Conservatives and Lib Dems; the Liberal Democrats held their seat last year on a rather low share of the vote, 36% to 29% for the Conservatives and 19% for UKIP. In May's Surrey county elections the local Caterham Hill division produced a photo-finish, the Liberal Democrats holding their seat by just 12 votes.

Defending for the Liberal Democrats is Helen Rujbally, a local resident who works supporting people with learnings disabilities: she was a victim of flash-flooding in 2016. Alex Standen is standing for the Conservatives; he was a UKIP candidate in the 2016 local elections. The official UKIP candidate is Helena Windsor, a former Surrey county councillor (Godstone, 2013-17). Completing the ballot paper is Labour candidate Lucy McNally.

Parliamentary constituency: East Surrey
Surrey county council division: Caterham Hill
ONS Travel to Work Area: London (part); Crawley (part)
Postcode district: CR3

Lucy McNally (Lab)
Helen Rujbally (LD)
Alex Standen (C)
Helena Windsor (UKIP)

May 2016 result LD 416 C 335 UKIP 220 Lab 183
May 2014 result C 358 LD 265 UKIP 243 Lab 155
May 2012 result LD 496 C 204 Lab 120 UKIP 79
May 2010 result C 828 LD 799 Lab 158 UKIP 106
May 2008 result LD 573 C 485 Lab 70
May 2006 result C 584 LD 414 Lab 97
June 2004 result C 521 LD 232 Lab 181
May 2002 result C 477 Lab 344 LD 127
May 2000 result C 447/440 Lab 327/320 LD 181/138

Bridgemary North

Gosport council, Hampshire; caused by the death of Labour councillor Jill Wright at the age of 69. The Mayoress of Gosport in 2001-02, Wright was first elected to Gosport council in 1997 for Rowner ward, transferring to Bridgemary South ward in 2002. She lost her seat in 2008 but returned to the council in 2012 for Bridgemary North ward. Away from the council, Wright worked for 26 years as practice manager at the Bridgemary medical centre.

We travel south-west from Caterham to the Solent conurbation. This is a badly-planned area of large towns and associated housing estates, with Bridgemary being one of the largest estates. Almost entirely developed since the Second World War, this is the northern end of the town of Gosport hard up against the border with Fareham. Gosport is of course a naval town, and within the boundaries of Bridgemary North ward is Fleetlands Heliport, opened during the war as a naval air yard and now used as a maintenance base for both military and civil helicopters. Also within the ward is the misleadingly-named Fareham Business Park, home to the book printers Ashford Colour Press and the pharmaceutical testing company Wickham Laboratories. So, despite the ward's low qualification levels (it is just outside the top 100 in the UK for those with between 1 and 5 GCSE passes or equivalent) there are plenty of jobs here.

The ward was created in 2002 as part of a major reorganisation of Gosport's wards, in which the town became one of the handful of English districts to introduce the system of election by halves. Bridgemary North's working-class economic profile normally creates a safe Labour ward, although the Conservatives did win here in 2008 with a majority of just 50 votes. Jill Wright recovered that loss for Labour in 2012 to rejoin on the council her husband Dennis, who is the ward's other councillor. In 2016 Jill was re-elected for the last time, beating the Conservatives 72-28 in a straight fight. However, Labour did very badly here in May's county elections, losing their seat in the Bridgemary division and actually falling to third place behind the Tories and Lib Dems.

Defending for Labour is local resident James Fox, who is retired after a career spent working for local firms and the MoD. The Conservative candidate Richard Dickson is hoping to make a quick return to the council after losing his seat in Christchurch ward in 2016; he had represented that ward since 2004 and was Mayor of Gosport in 2012-13. Completing the ballot paper is Stephen Hammond, who has been tempted by his second-place performance in May's county elections to become the ward's first Liberal Democrat candidate.

Parliamentary constituency: Gosport
Hampshire county council division: Bridgemary
ONS Travel to Work Area: Portsmouth
Postcode district: PO13

Richard Dickson (C)
James Fox (Lab)
Stephen Hammond (LD)

May 2016 result Lab 796 C 310
May 2014 result Lab 829 C 331
May 2012 result Lab 708 C 418
May 2010 result Lab 1002 C 733 EDP 381
May 2008 result C 594 Lab 544
May 2006 result Lab 809 C 384
June 2004 result Lab 643 C 473
May 2002 result Lab 814/795 C 253/235


Torridge council, Devon; caused by the resignation of councillor Roger Darch, who had been elected for the UK Independence Party but was sitting as an independent.

For our final poll of the week we enter the West Country. Readers of Henry Williamson's Tarka the Otter will have an image in their mind's eye of the Torridge valley, of which Great Torrington is the major settlement. Williamson's work has brought some tourists to the town, which still retains a large number of independent shops because it's too small and remote to interest the national chains. However, the largest employer in the town is glass-making: Dartington Crystal runs the UK's last remaining crystal factory here.

This market town may be tiny, but in 1958 Torrington gave its name to a parliamentary seat which was gained by the Liberal Party in a famous by-election. More recent results in the town have been fragmented: this is the sort of area where a local independent can build up a high profile, and long-serving independent councillor Margaret Brown has developed a clear personal vote to do just that. In the 2007 election her ward colleagues were a Conservative and a Liberal Democrat; the Lib Dem councillor resigned in 2013 as he was moving to Norfolk, and the party did not defend the resulting by-election which was won by the Green Party's Cathrine Simmons. Brown and Simmons were re-elected in first and second place in 2015, with the Conservatives losing their seat to UKIP's Roger Darch; shares of the vote were 25% for Brown, 22% for the Greens, 21% for UKIP and 20% for the Conservatives. The Tories had a big lead in the local county seat (Torrington Rural) in May, with UKIP's Darch falling to fourth place. On a more sour note, a by-election in August to Great Torrington town council - which has the same boundaries as this ward - created controversy after the (unsuccessful) Liberal Democrat candidate reportedly sent an explicit picture of himself dressed as a mouse to the (unsuccessful) Labour candidate.

Hopefully this by-election will be more decorous, although anyone without local knowledge would be hard-pressed to pick a winner. Defending for UKIP is John Pitts, secretary of Great Torrington bowls club and Darch's running-mate here in 2015. Standing as an independent candidate is Di Davey, who has recently succeeded Darch as Deputy Mayor of Great Torrington. The Green Party have selected Sue Clarke, who is a teacher. Returning from the 2015 election is the Conservatives' Harold Martin, who is seeking to return to Torridge council; he represented Two Rivers ward from 2011 to 2015 when he unsuccessfully sought election here. Completing the ballot paper is Liberal Democrat candidate Cheryl Cottle-Hunkin, a teacher and sheep farmer.

Parliamentary constituency: Torridge and West Devon
Devon county council division: Torrington Rural
ONS Travel to Work Area: Bideford
Postcode district: EX38

Sue Clarke (Grn)
Cheryl Cottle-Hunkin (LD)
Di Davey (Ind)
Harold Martin (C)
John Pitts (UKIP)

May 2015 result Ind 986 Grn 901/627 UKIP 841/659 C 786/736 Lab 496
September 2013 by-election Grn 292 UKIP 181 Ind 160 Ind 106 C 88
May 2011 result C 809 Ind 792/480 LD 641/209 Lab 312 UKIP 208
May 2007 result Ind 693/490/476/179 C 620 LD 495 Grn 352
May 2003 result Ind 645/424/254 LD 376/364/243 Grn 212

If you liked this piece, please consider supporting future columns by buying the book! Andrew's Previews 2016, containing many more pieces like this, is now available from Amazon.